First topic message reminder :

Hi guys,I've been wanting to be a critic since a long time ago and now I finally have the time to do this..
anyways,I've been singing since I was 3 years old..All my life there's not a day without music and singing..So I do know a thing or two about music ;) I've been making youtube covers since 2009 and I used to take vocal lessons too..I mostly know K-pop and western songs..any language is fine but I wouldn't be able to critic your pronounciation..I will critic you with a 0%-100% notation..
Maximum 1 clips per person..
you have to wait for a week before posting another clip..

Fill this form if u want to be criticed:
-Song:
-Artist:
-Video or mp3:

Song Challenge:
KOREAN:
-SNSD - Complete
-IU - Good Day
-IU - You&I
-T-ara feat. Davichi - We were in love
-JYJ - In Heaven
-Apink - I don't know
-Brown Eyed Girls - Sixth Sense

ENGLISH:
-Cascada - What hurts the most
-Kelly Clarkson - Mr.Know it all
-Jessie J - Price Tag
-Katy Perry - ET
-Katy Perry - TGIF
-Nicki Minaj - Superbass

Notes: Be careful of what you wish for because I might hurt you with my words :ryuko:

Song : A Goose Dream [Accapella] Suzy ft Eunjung Version
Artis : Suzy ft Eunjung
Video :


PS : I'm the one with blue shirt, thanks :)

celrish93 wrote:

Song : A Goose Dream [Accapella] Suzy ft Eunjung Version
Artis : Suzy ft Eunjung
Video :


PS : I'm the one with blue shirt, thanks :)

yup gonna give this a 100% out of 100% for sure :3
you guys are AH-MA-ZING!!!! both are so talented and I love the harmony..but there are something I'd like to say about the girl in the right..she sounds a little forced when singing the high notes..well,other than that I can't say anything..I'm just so speechless o_o and also I can't believe you both are from Indonesia your pronounciations are perfect..Good luck fellow Indonesian coverist!! hope you'll become famous in youtube someday..both of you..

Song: Bad Boy
-Artist:Big Bang
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKhBlJdjDgE
it is bad boy with a bit of a twist. i entered into the big bang competition so if you could head over to the yg website, find it and give it a like, that would be really appreciated. i would give a direct link but there isn't one mianhae

anyway i know it's not perfect but i tried

KunoichiofDestinyKasumi wrote:

Song: Bad Boy
-Artist:Big Bang
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKhBlJdjDgE
it is bad boy with a bit of a twist. i entered into the big bang competition so if you could head over to the yg website, find it and give it a like, that would be really appreciated. i would give a direct link but there isn't one mianhae

anyway i know it's not perfect but i tried

I'm gonna rate this 95% out of 100%
It is really good ^^ I like how you make the song sounds cheerful and It really suits your voice..you did a great job..well,the only problem I had is your korean pronounciation..need more practice on that..but overall you did really great..I tried to vote for you but I had to search all the entries one by one.. :/ but I liked it..hope that helps..

Rie wrote:

KunoichiofDestinyKasumi wrote:

Song: Bad Boy
-Artist:Big Bang
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKhBlJdjDgE
it is bad boy with a bit of a twist. i entered into the big bang competition so if you could head over to the yg website, find it and give it a like, that would be really appreciated. i would give a direct link but there isn't one mianhae

anyway i know it's not perfect but i tried

I'm gonna rate this 95% out of 100%
It is really good ^^ I like how you make the song sounds cheerful and It really suits your voice..you did a great job..well,the only problem I had is your korean pronounciation..need more practice on that..but overall you did really great..I tried to vote for you but I had to search all the entries one by one.. :/ but I liked it..hope that helps..

Thank you, yeah my pronounciation is kinda way off. I think it was because i was going too fast oh well. Thank you for the like anyway. I did update the video so there is a easier to vote for the video. if you could just look at the description on my video it tells you an easier way to find the video. Thank you anyway. could you hep spread my video aswell. i know i''m asking for quite a lot but i really want to try and get as far as possible in the competition.

KunoichiofDestinyKasumi wrote:

Rie wrote:

KunoichiofDestinyKasumi wrote:

Song: Bad Boy
-Artist:Big Bang
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKhBlJdjDgE
it is bad boy with a bit of a twist. i entered into the big bang competition so if you could head over to the yg website, find it and give it a like, that would be really appreciated. i would give a direct link but there isn't one mianhae

anyway i know it's not perfect but i tried

I'm gonna rate this 95% out of 100%
It is really good ^^ I like how you make the song sounds cheerful and It really suits your voice..you did a great job..well,the only problem I had is your korean pronounciation..need more practice on that..but overall you did really great..I tried to vote for you but I had to search all the entries one by one.. :/ but I liked it..hope that helps..

Thank you, yeah my pronounciation is kinda way off. I think it was because i was going too fast oh well. Thank you for the like anyway. I did update the video so there is a easier to vote for the video. if you could just look at the description on my video it tells you an easier way to find the video. Thank you anyway. could you hep spread my video aswell. i know i''m asking for quite a lot but i really want to try and get as far as possible in the competition.

no,I found the link already but I had to look for your video from all the entry..and as you see they have a LOT of entries..I can't look for it one by one can I.. :/ I tried to open with the link that you provide but that didn't work as well :( I really want to help you but I can't..

Song : Price Tag
Artist : Jessie J
Video : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnA0V8k_f_I&feature=relmfu
I want you to critic my old cover because it's in your song challenges =)

AnihJourney wrote:

Song : Price Tag
Artist : Jessie J
Video : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnA0V8k_f_I&feature=relmfu
I want you to critic my old cover because it's in your song challenges =)

I'm going to rate this 95% out of 100%
I really love your voice here ^^ It's really beautiful..and what I really like the most is that you kinda made the song into your own..It's really good ^^ again my only complain is the pronounciation...but other than that you're flawless :) thanks for trying out my song challange..

Rie wrote:

AnihJourney wrote:

Song : Price Tag
Artist : Jessie J
Video : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnA0V8k_f_I&feature=relmfu
I want you to critic my old cover because it's in your song challenges =)

I'm going to rate this 95% out of 100%
I really love your voice here ^^ It's really beautiful..and what I really like the most is that you kinda made the song into your own..It's really good ^^ again my only complain is the pronounciation...but other than that you're flawless :) thanks for trying out my song challange..

Oh thanks... I'm surprised... Because I prefer my «When you say nothing at all» x100 compared to this one =))
Pronunciation is my weakness. Even in my language, french =))

Song : 我们就到这
Artist : FISH
Link : http://www.box.com/s/dtdr3e62nnjro8rvjzfp

Shiori wrote:

Song : 我们就到这
Artist : FISH
Link : http://www.box.com/s/dtdr3e62nnjro8rvjzfp

I'm gonna rate this 65% out of 100%
This sound pitchy..It's better than the last cover you sent to me but still a lot of the melody is out of pitch..you tend to sound like you're holding back your voice,try to just release your voice without holding it back,I think it would be better..I like your emotions though..Keep on practicing,dear ^^

Song: Message
-Artist: MYNAME
-Video or mp3:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rcARWTi6S2U

KunoichiofDestinyKasumi wrote:

Song: Message
-Artist: MYNAME
-Video or mp3:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rcARWTi6S2U

I'm gonna rate this 95% out of 100% ^^
I like this so much,you have a really beautiful voice :3 I really like your cover..I think your pronounciation here is definetely better than the last cover you sent me..the only thing I'd like to complain about is your pitch is kinda flat sometimes,but not often..so overall I think you did a really good job!!

-Song: Ugly
-Artist: 2ne1
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vygOBOeU_ng

PiggyMelody wrote:

-Song: Ugly
-Artist: 2ne1
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vygOBOeU_ng

omo,how could I just saw this now :/ so sorry for haven't been checking this topic..

I'm gonna rate this 88% out of 100%
I think you have a really great voice and I love your energy..just lacks a little bit of voice control..like in 1:04 - 1:11 and 3:12 - 3:19 is a little out of pitch..I really like your higher notes in the chorus.. (the "pretty") ^^ I think overall you did great..

-Song: You & I
-Artist: IU
-Video or mp3:

I took your challenge without knowing it T.T

-Song: I Don't Know
-Artist: A Pink
-Video or mp3: http://www.box.com/s/f6fd079e38cdfa90f2fd

(Not the full song.)

skyangerzx wrote:

-Song: You & I
-Artist: IU
-Video or mp3:

I took your challenge without knowing it T.T

I'm gonna give you 87% out of 100%
Your voice is really high pitch :D It's really beautiful,I only have two problem,first is your pronounciation..It isn't that bad but there are some unclear pronouncing in the chorus..second,you somehow sounds so forced troughout the chorus..I think you just need a little practice to master this song..since your voice is high pitched anyway..I know this song is super hard to sing so I gotta give you credit for that :D great job!!

ElOhVeeEeh1 wrote:

-Song: I Don't Know
-Artist: A Pink
-Video or mp3: http://www.box.com/s/f6fd079e38cdfa90f2fd

(Not the full song.)

I'm gonna give this 100% out of 100%
I can't find a single flaw in this cover o_o you're really good..I love your harmonization too..you even hit Eunji notes so easily..pronounciation is also perfect..I don't know what to say..It's really flawless :/

Rie wrote:

I'm gonna give you 87% out of 100%
Your voice is really high pitch :D It's really beautiful,I only have two problem,first is your pronounciation..It isn't that bad but there are some unclear pronouncing in the chorus..second,you somehow sounds so forced troughout the chorus..I think you just need a little practice to master this song..since your voice is high pitched anyway..I know this song is super hard to sing so I gotta give you credit for that :D great job!!

Thanks! You're the best ^^ I noticed that with my chorus too (the forced part). I felt like I was shouting, which isn't that good T.T Do you have any advice on singing higher without forcing it?

Rie wrote:

I'm gonna give this 100% out of 100%
I can't find a single flaw in this cover o_o you're really good..I love your harmonization too..you even hit Eunji notes so easily..pronounciation is also perfect..I don't know what to say..It's really flawless :/

Wow..! Thank you so much.. I was totally not expecting that... XD

skyangerzx wrote:

Rie wrote:

I'm gonna give you 87% out of 100%
Your voice is really high pitch :D It's really beautiful,I only have two problem,first is your pronounciation..It isn't that bad but there are some unclear pronouncing in the chorus..second,you somehow sounds so forced troughout the chorus..I think you just need a little practice to master this song..since your voice is high pitched anyway..I know this song is super hard to sing so I gotta give you credit for that :D great job!!

Thanks! You're the best ^^ I noticed that with my chorus too (the forced part). I felt like I was shouting, which isn't that good T.T Do you have any advice on singing higher without forcing it?

The only advice I could give to you is practice :3 If you ever heard my old covers you can see that my voice wasn't high pitch at all..so I started to practice by singing songs that are out of my range (IU songs are a good example) hope my little advice can make you sing higher pitch easily.. :D

I want ..(:
I hope its okay with indonesia song..x)


-Song: karena kusuka dirimu (kimi no koto ga suki dakara)
-Artist: JKT48
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2fXd29lIP1M&list=UU8zZGeBTUzOyuSbJmsavQXQ&index=1&feature=plcp

sakisaki wrote:

I want ..(:
I hope its okay with indonesia song..x)


-Song: karena kusuka dirimu (kimi no koto ga suki dakara)
-Artist: JKT48
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2fXd29lIP1M&list=UU8zZGeBTUzOyuSbJmsavQXQ&index=1&feature=plcp

I'm gonna rate this 90% out of 100%
I like your energy and I think your voice is really sweet :3
the only thing I'd like to complain about is your mic..It really is the only problem I had with your cover..your mic minimize the beauty of your voice..If you get what I mean..sorry for my bad english :/

Rie wrote:

I'm gonna rate this 90% out of 100%
I like your energy and I think your voice is really sweet :3
the only thing I'd like to complain about is your mic..It really is the only problem I had with your cover..your mic minimize the beauty of your voice..If you get what I mean..sorry for my bad english :/

really!? thanks rie,,(:
and honestly I have problem with high note too..o_o"

ahh, could you reccomend me some good mic by headphone?? I think I cant make it if using any stand mic..(:

no problem, I didnt really good in english either,,x)

sakisaki wrote:

Rie wrote:

I'm gonna rate this 90% out of 100%
I like your energy and I think your voice is really sweet :3
the only thing I'd like to complain about is your mic..It really is the only problem I had with your cover..your mic minimize the beauty of your voice..If you get what I mean..sorry for my bad english :/

really!? thanks rie,,(:
and honestly I have problem with high note too..o_o"

ahh, could you reccomend me some good mic by headphone?? I think I cant make it if using any stand mic..(:

no problem, I didnt really good in english either,,x)

Hmm,I'm currently using Logitech clear chat premium PC headset..I think it is decent enough..even though it's not crystal clear like profesional USB mic..

thanks rie!~ I'll try to search it here..(:

Hi rieee I want your opinion about this~ :D

-Song: Warrior
-Artist: B.A.P
-Video or mp3:

Stellaniou wrote:

Hi rieee I want your opinion about this~ :D

-Song: Warrior
-Artist: B.A.P
-Video or mp3:

I'm gonna rate this 95% out of 100%
First of all oh my god your Zelo rap is awesome!!! I really did enjoy this cover ^^ you're strong and powerful voice really showed here..the only thing I'd like to critic about is the Bang Yongguk part at the beginning sounds a little awkward to me (sorry ><) maybe it's because Bang yong guk voice is really low..while your voice isn't at that range..(you're a girl after all :D) but overall I think you did a really great job!!

Song: Heaven
Artist : Ailee
Link: http://www.4shared.com/mp3/jQuZTHuh/Ailee_-_Heaven_Cover.html

i know i'm no Ailee however i did try. i don't if my emotion got through when sing this but i did try and i know there are some pitch problems with my backing vocals. this is song is deffinately not in my comfort zone but i did try.

Song: Love, My Love
Artist: Davichi
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LXW0T1hA98

Well I was trying to go for one of your challenge songs, but I think I'll just try it after a week >,< Anyways yeah... thank you for taking the time to critic this! ^_^ I really want to improve

KunoichiofDestinyKasumi wrote:

Song: Heaven
Artist : Ailee
Link: http://www.4shared.com/mp3/jQuZTHuh/Ailee_-_Heaven_Cover.html

i know i'm no Ailee however i did try. i don't if my emotion got through when sing this but i did try and i know there are some pitch problems with my backing vocals. this is song is deffinately not in my comfort zone but i did try.

I'm gonna rate this 70% out of 100%
First of all you lack of voice control..at the beginning of the song you sounded unstable..you have some pronounciation problem too..the chorus is pitchy here and there..I like your second verse though,It sounded more stable than the first one..I really like the bridge too..overall I think this is not your best cover,especially after hearing your other covers..I know you could do better :D just keep practicing 'kay?

Daphne wrote:

Song: Love, My Love
Artist: Davichi
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LXW0T1hA98

Well I was trying to go for one of your challenge songs, but I think I'll just try it after a week >,< Anyways yeah... thank you for taking the time to critic this! ^_^ I really want to improve

I'm gonna rate this 95% out of 100%
you have an amazing high voice :D I love your voice control and you hit those high notes perfectly..this is really good for a oneshot cover!! but you should've sang with trough your diagphram..It'll make you sing stronger and more powerful..because you definetely have the voice,you just need the right technique..hwaiting!! ^^

@Rie

Wa! I'm surprised~~ I sang this on easter in a room while all the other adults were having fun w/ their karaoke =,= (80s stuff I'll never be able to join)

Anyways thanks! ^_^ And I'll work on my breathing! With exercises and what not~

Rie wrote:

KunoichiofDestinyKasumi wrote:

Song: Heaven
Artist : Ailee
Link: http://www.4shared.com/mp3/jQuZTHuh/Ailee_-_Heaven_Cover.html

i know i'm no Ailee however i did try. i don't if my emotion got through when sing this but i did try and i know there are some pitch problems with my backing vocals. this is song is deffinately not in my comfort zone but i did try.

I'm gonna rate this 70% out of 100%
First of all you lack of voice control..at the beginning of the song you sounded unstable..you have some pronounciation problem too..the chorus is pitchy here and there..I like your second verse though,It sounded more stable than the first one..I really like the bridge too..overall I think this is not your best cover,especially after hearing your other covers..I know you could do better :D just keep practicing 'kay?

*sigh* i know. deffinately not my best cover. I don't think this song is for me. I guess i just wanted to try because i am a big fan of Ailee. I was going to post this on my youtube channel but thank you for telling me this. i am deffinately not proud of this cover anyway. i think i will give you another cover to review next week which i hope will be better. Oh and i didn't get into the 2nd round of the Big Bang Competition oh well i guess i just have to keep trying

-Song: All happy
-Artist: Ah-Fu
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukK6JNWUUDo

Thank you <3

PiggyMelody wrote:

-Song: All happy
-Artist: Ah-Fu
-Video or mp3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukK6JNWUUDo

Thank you <3

I'm gonna rate this 90% out of 100%
I gotta say you've improved so much ^^ to me I think this is the best cover that you've ever sent to me :D
You sounded so cute and energetic,I like that ^^ but there are flaws too,some flat notes and I think it's gonna sound even better if you didn't put the echo effects at 1:34 - 1:41
Keep on practicing and do well :D 加油!!

@Rie ; omgosh <3 thank you ^^

I'm baaaaaaack!
-Song: My My
-Artist: A PINK
-Video or mp3:

Thanks in advance :)

skyangerzx wrote:

I'm baaaaaaack!
-Song: My My
-Artist: A PINK
-Video or mp3:

Thanks in advance :)

I'm gonna rate this 85% out of 100%
I really like your energy that you put in this cover ^^ and you don't really have many pitch problems but you have many pronounciation problem..the first verse is quite hard to understand (this may not occured to some people but I memorized the lyrics),the chorus too It should've been "Geu jarie Ttak,Gogi" but you sang it "Geu jarie,Gogi"..Other than that I just wanna say your adlibs are amazing <3 you can reach those high notes like Eunji,that's awesome!! just practice your pronouncition and you'll be more awesome <3 hehe..

-Song: When I Can't Sing
-Artist: SE7EN
-Video or mp3:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nIvujTW-1Ec

Hopefully this better than my last cover. I tried really hard and it has a lot of meaning to me

KunoichiofDestinyKasumi wrote:

-Song: When I Can't Sing
-Artist: SE7EN
-Video or mp3:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nIvujTW-1Ec

Hopefully this better than my last cover. I tried really hard and it has a lot of meaning to me

I'm gonna give you a 95% out of 100%
I can totally feel your emotions in this cover,this cover totally sounds amazing and is definetly better than your last cover..but you still have some flat notes,they're not many but I can still hear it :3 anyways aside from that I think you're getting better and better at singing :D remember practice makes perfect!! <3

Song: Nagging
Artist: IU (ft. Seulong)
Video:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0VqjEFRJ9UQ

Song: Peach
Artist: IU
Video: but it's a short audio clip :S
https://www.box.com/s/7974debbe449e378f4a5

I did this song just for...umm...like...a practice? very short , lol
And most of time in chorus i use my falsetto (it's more suits with the song's atmosphere) , but not all the time if you can heard....
and i want to know ur opinion :)

cloudymelody wrote:

Song: Nagging
Artist: IU (ft. Seulong)
Video:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0VqjEFRJ9UQ

I'm gonna rate this 78% out of 100%
You have a really soft and pretty voice but I think you don't know how to control it well..there's a lot of part where you sang it wrong..some flat notes and wrong pitches are detected..but honestly I think you have a lot of potential to be a great coversit ^^ your voice is so soothing and beautiful,you just have to control it the right way..just keep on practicing :D

Stellaniou wrote:

Song: Peach
Artist: IU
Video: but it's a short audio clip :S
https://www.box.com/s/7974debbe449e378f4a5

I did this song just for...umm...like...a practice? very short , lol
And most of time in chorus i use my falsetto (it's more suits with the song's atmosphere) , but not all the time if you can heard....
and i want to know ur opinion :)

90% out of 100%
Your voice is so beautiful ^^ love love love the harmony..the only thing I'd like to say is that you tend to go flat when near the end of your singing..I don't know why..and also to me the "Baby~" is a tad weird.. >< but if you just work on that I'm sure It's gonna be a perfect cover

-Song: UGLY (Japanese ver)
-Artist: 2NE1
-Video or mp3: see siggy~

shioЯi wrote:

-Song: UGLY (Japanese ver)
-Artist: 2NE1
-Video or mp3: see siggy~

I'm gonna rate this 60% out of 100%
I'm so sorry but this cover is just not...not really good..I'm sorry >< I think you went wrong pitched most of the time but there are some parts that you sang okay..I like the first verse best..but other than that you mostly sing out of tune or flat.. Learn how to sing trough your diaphragm and also don't stretch your notes when you sing (when you sing you tend to stretch the last note)

I think that is all..sorry for being so harsh

Rie wrote:

Stellaniou wrote:

Song: Peach
Artist: IU
Video: but it's a short audio clip :S
https://www.box.com/s/7974debbe449e378f4a5

I did this song just for...umm...like...a practice? very short , lol
And most of time in chorus i use my falsetto (it's more suits with the song's atmosphere) , but not all the time if you can heard....
and i want to know ur opinion :)

90% out of 100%
Your voice is so beautiful ^^ love love love the harmony..the only thing I'd like to say is that you tend to go flat when near the end of your singing..I don't know why..and also to me the "Baby~" is a tad weird.. >< but if you just work on that I'm sure It's gonna be a perfect cover

kkkk thankyou :)
that's been my issue till now, i don't have a good ability to control my voice at the end of words :/

Rie!!~ I'm here againn..><

Song: Egao ni Namida ~ Thank you Dear my Friends
Artist: Niigaki Risa ~ Matsuura Aya
Video: